Well, this to be another huge surprise, favor last week’s illustration of My little Pony: Friendship is Magic. That illustration made me litter aside mine intended weekly evaluation for an 11th hour evaluation of that game-changing episode.

You are watching: My little pony: friendship is magic season 5 episode 19

This week’s illustration wasn’t as big of a deal, yet like Crusaders the the shed Mark, it’s been playing over-and-over, and is still providing me with some laughs. Ergo, ns felt I have to expound a little on the recent episode: The One wherein Pinkie Pie Knows.


While functioning at Sugarcube Corner, grandm Cake lets Pinkie Pie check out an upcoming order, in relationship to an brewing visit native Shining Armor, and also Princess Cadance (Twilight Sparkle’s Brother, and her Sister-in-law). The order reveals something super-secret, the Mrs Cake swears Pinkie come secrecy on.

Can the excitable pink pony store this secret from she friends and every one of Ponyville…and keep her sanity?


From previous experience, Pinkie Pie has regularly been the odd-pony-out that the show’s “Mane 6” cast. Though she deserve to be a small over-excited at times, she often method well, and tries her ideal to be friends with everybody.

She has had actually some episodes in the previous that i still like to clock (such together Season 1’s episode Party the One, and Season 4’s illustration Pinkie Pride), yet sometimes, her characterization can make-or-break one ensemble episode.

Gillian M Berrow (aka G.M. Berrow) has been connected with the collection for awhile now, yet only in regards to number of of the series’ chapter-books, and Equestria Girls book adaptations. Pinkie Knows is her first official writing for the series, and also it serves together an interesting episode to dissect.

This episode has a weird “habit,” of punctuating specific scenes with minor flashbacks, which if we see some further episodes created by Berrow, might be miscellaneous to watch for, to watch if this can be one of her recurring writing “trademarks.” The flashbacks didn’t yes, really detract native the story, but they go strike me as having actually a “oh yeah, currently that you point out it” feel to them.

The story likewise plays about a little bit with pushing several of the characters and scenarios, something that writer Dave Polsky does rather a little with his episodes. However, unlike several of his episodes the seem to have a few-too-many hoax or scenarios that fall flat, so lot of what Berrow go here, actually works well, mostly thanks come the situations, and also what the animators in ~ DHX do with Pinkie Pie.

It feels like Andrea Libman really gained the chance to perform a little much more with Pinkie’s voice in this episode. Libman’s voice seems to squash-and-stretch through Pinkie’s ever-changing attitudes and also scenarios, running the gamut of happy, sad, annoyed, nervous, hyper, and many more. Even Pinkie’s small moments of small-talk through herself room entertaining, through a couple of lines the really make me laugh out loud.

An added bonus come the episode, is the visitation of bright Armor and also Cadance. Though your time is relegated come a very tiny amount, it to be nice to see them in a situation where they were no under duress like nearly all their previous appearances (seriously, i was beginning to concern for Cadance after she last few outings!). Plus, we gain one the the ideal brother/sister moments between Twilight and also Shining, since the very first episode the A Canterlot Wedding.

Where the episode might fall brief in the eyes of many, is that it does obtain a tiny ‘long in the tooth’ through every-other-pony express something that in some method relates to the mystery Pinkie is trying to keep. A ‘secret-keeping’ episode I feel might maybe job-related in a smaller-dosed, 7-11 minute segment/episode (or comic publication storyline).

When other like Pinkie Knows is extended out end 22 minutes, it becomes a bit of a chore to store the bits interesting. Berrow I will certainly say, does perform a decent task on the episode, but it feels prefer it every goes on a small too long.

The various other ‘Mane 6’ personalities that space not Pinkie or Twilight, have actually been largely relegated to the cheerleading box for this episode, providing a couple of lines here-and-there, depending on the situation. Together well, the townsponies nearly feel prefer the old-school lift ponies the come front to assistance the story, depending upon what ‘mood’ the episode needs them come be.

See more: Proof Square Root Of 3 Is Irrational ? Prove That Root 3 Is Irrational Number

In that way, The One where Pinkie Pie Knows is an illustration that practically feels choose it could fit right right into the an initial 2 seasons. The does remind me a bit of episodes choose The Ticket Master, Green Isn’t your Color, or even A Bird in The Hoof.


Final episode Grade: B

(Final episode Thoughts: G.M. Berrow helms her very first television illustration of My small Pony, and also delivers a funny story, that almost feels choose a shed episode native the first few seasons. Despite it does acquire a little flimsy with the way it keeps taunting Pinkie Pie to spill she secret, the episode never ever grows boring, thanks in part to Andrea Libman’s vocals, and also the means the show’s animators store doing so much with Pinkie’s animation. As well, the extr interaction in between Twilight Sparkle, shining Armor, and also Princess Cadance, verified to work a bit far better than your last few meetings)