Now the the can be fried Court has thrown the hearty embrace around the appropriate of asymmetrical actors to go into agreements robbing the weaker party the their basic rights, it’s absolutely passé come worry around the rights virtually every American indications away every day by mere virtue of owning a cabinet phone. Those onerous client agreements constantly lock consumers into binding arbitration. However we already knew phone call cusotmers were permanently screwed by the Concepcion decision.

You are watching: South park i am above the law

In a current decision about a compelled arbitration clause in the fine publish of a convoluted Verizon agreement, referee Roberta Colton, a Bankruptcy judge in the center District of Florida, express the frustration all of us with a passing knowledge of basic fairness feels when it comes to clauses like this:

Although the court is cynical that the arbitration agreement between Mr. Bateman and Verizon important is a negotiated contract within the definition of a statute enacted in 1925, specifically since Verizon deserve to unilaterally adjust any ax at any type of time, the supreme Court does not distinguish in between consumer and also commercial arbitration…


It’s no secret that BigLaw associates are working harder than ever. But prior to you think of leaving BigLaw altogether, take into consideration whether a readjust of BigLaw…

Yeah. That certainly isn’t what conference would have intended, but looking at legislative intent is because that wusses! but Judge Colton knows she hands space tied. Speaking of being unnaturally bound… here’s the pop culture reference she evoked to carry this unfortunate quirk of the legislation to life. In footnote 37, she notes:

The court is reminded that an illustration from the cartoon collection “South Park” in i beg your pardon Apple pertains to town and also demands blood from iphone customers because a supplication to provide up her blood was buried in the consumer organization agreement the everyone in southern Park had agreed come by merely clicking a box, yet of course never ever read. (Trey Parker, 15 HumancentiPad south Park (2011)).

Um. That’s no really the takeaway from that episode. Mine recollection that that illustration isn’t therefore much about taking everyone’s blood — in fact, a key element the that episode is the truth that no one in south Park had signed the business agreement other than Kyle. And what Kyle learned, come his horror, is the this contract the adhesion fairly literally adhered him come the anus of an additional careless apple user in a human being centipede. Favor this:



The win candidates will occupational with the one of the most diversified an innovation practice groups in the country.

So, did judge Colton self-censor her opinion by transporting a false narrative of south Park history? probably shielding united state from the mental anguish of having to take into consideration “cuttlefish” again (you understand what that way if you’ve seen this episode)?

Or possibly she really doesn’t remember it. Which would be a shame, because perhaps if judge Colton mental the episode more accurately, she’d have actually felt much more emboldened to break with precedent to protect the poor defendant prior to he finished up an additional cruel experiment in Verizon’s dungeon.

(Read the full opinion ~ above the next page…)

Joe Patriceis one editor at above the Law and co-host the Thinking prefer A Lawyer. Feel free toemail any type of tips, questions, or comments. Monitor him onTwitterif you’re interested in law, politics, and also a healthy and balanced dose of college sporting activities news.

Above the Law day-to-day newsletter

Sign up and get the recent news in your inbox.

Subscribe Now

We will never sell or re-superstructure your info without your consent. View our privacy policy.


Yawn: can be fried Court reform commission comes ago with… not lot of anything.

Interesting Timing: by pure coincidence, the the supervisory board report the couldn’t number out if there could be a legitimacy trouble with a life-tenured high priesthood that a can be fried Court released their findings simply in time because that Clarence cutting board to celebrate 30 year on the Court.

Critical gyeongju Theory… whereby The actual Money Is: Wingnuts think Merrick Garland is making use of the DOJ to gain rich off critical race theory or something.

Don’t Envy The certain PR Team: Mayer Brown was helping China crackdown on Hong Kong. Yeesh.

There’s No Such thing As A free Lunch. Never Mind: Kirkland & Ellis is bringing folks back to the office, however at the very least you get free breakfast and also lunch.

See more: Eli5: Why Do Actors Get Paid So Much, Do Actors Get Paid Too Much

The Emperor has No Cybersecurity: Missouri is threaten a journalist with “noticing things in the first degree” after ~ figuring the end that the state accidentally post the social defense numbers of a bunch the teachers.

By Joe Patrice

More From over the Law



Recording Testimony Is No Substitute for A Court Reporter

A digital recording is no substitute because that the neutrality and legitimacy that is inferred as soon as a court report is associated in recording the testimony that witnesses.