Finding worth at the tight finish position is essential in your fantasy football breeze — unless, the course, you do the wrong of taking among the brittle top men too early. Attracted Loftis and Jarad Wilk dispute which that the later-round options are the much better values:

Jimmy Graham vs. Martellus Bennett

Drew: This requires specific caveats: 1, the Graham slips beyond his mean draft place (beginning of sixth round in PPR leagues), and also 2, we should be satisfied with our repertoire of running backs and broad receivers with the very first several rounds. If we satisfy those criteria, then we would pay a premium because that Graham over Bennett. Graham has far better upside, and a background of transporting on upside. Bennett is in an violation with much more mouths to feed, and also lacks the historic dominance. Oh, and Lance Kendricks and also Richard Rodgers still room around.

You are watching: Tyler eifert or martellus bennett

Jarad: history means nothing once the Packers have equipped Aaron Rodgers through Jermichael Finley, Richard Rodgers, Brandon Bostick, Donald Lee and other no-names who have accounted for just 6,000 the Rodgers’ 36,000-plus yards. That is a different story as soon as you’re adding Bennett come the Packers’ pass-heavy violation — whereby he will certainly be, in ~ worst, the third target. He has averaged 93 targets and also 64 receptions because 2012, as well as five touchdowns (it most likely would have actually been more had he not missed 5 games in 2015). Bennett is a weapon that will be used.

Delanie pedestrian vs. Tyler Eifert

Drew: Here, the greater upside for Eifert is counter by a much lower floor. Over the past 4 seasons, Walker has actually missed just four games. In that same span, Eifert has mised 27 games. We additionally like QB Marcus Mariota’s chances of improvement much better than Andy Dalton’s.

Jarad: We? who’s this we you’re talk about? Mariota, that course, has the chance to improve, but, prefer Eifert, he have to stay ~ above the field. Eifert might have to let go 11 gamings over the previous two seasons, yet he go score 18 touchdowns and was targeted 121 times (including 19 in the red zone). The Titans signed Eric Decker, drafted Corey Davis and currently have Rishard Matthews (108 targets) and also DeMarco Murray (67 targets). Walker might be durable, but he is walking to lose targets.

See more: Elenco De Oscuro Deseo - Dark Desire (Tv Series)

Cameron Brate vs. O.J. Howard

Drew: Rookie tight ends routinely perform not produce huge fantasy numbers. Brate was a breakout performer critical season, and there is no factor to believe he will be phased out. In a keeper, we strike this differently, but in a redraft, we absolutely prefer Brate — plus you can get him cheaper/later.

Cameron BrateAP

Jarad: have you viewed O.J. Howard? at 6-foot-6, 251-pounds, the man is a matchup nightmare because that defenses, and also Brate average a mere 2.6 yards after the capture last season despite his position-high eight TDs. The up-and-coming Buccaneers did no draft Howard come sit behind a guy who was, up until last year, getting minimal playing time because that a team the finished critical in that is division. Brate was great last year, yet Howard is the future.

C.J. Fiedorowicz vs. Jason Witten

Drew: Witten is a known commodity. What is known is the he has become a ho-hum fantasy car option, best suited as a bye-week fill-in, if on her roster at all. Fiedorowicz need to be considered the same, albeit with some upside. His QB situation isn’t good (Tom Savage or rookie Deshaun Watson). However he made huge strides last year with Brock Oswelier as the main signal-caller, so at least duplicating those number (54 catches, 559 yards, four TDs) is likely, and improvement is highly possible. Witten is what the is (averaging 70 receptions, 696 yards, 4 TDs over past three years), and has a far better chance of decrease than improvement. Offer me the ceiling.

Jarad: Witten might no longer be the must-own tight end he once was, however old and reliable have been working with each other for a lengthy time. His number may have actually slipped end the last couple of seasons, yet he is durable, playing in all 16 games every season due to the fact that 2007. He also has average 114 targets, 81 receptions, 888 yards and also five touchdowns since 2004. Fiedorowicz may be 10 years younger, but we’re talking about a player who will most likely be a No. 2 tight end, that will be provided in an emergency or top top a farewell week. That would you rather depend on? A young man who has actually potential and also a below average QB situation? Or a proven veteran in a good situation who has always been a trusted fantasy option? I know my answer.